Bagel Cafe

Baychester, Bronx

Bagel Cafe
View On OpenSea

Total Score

Ranks & Awards

3.17 / 5
#10 in Bronx #174 in NYC

Store: A long, deep store with strangely dim yellow lighting as you progress to the back. The effect is an aura of suspicion, like a thieves guild for bagels. Despite being the only customer in the store and having time to prepare for my approach, they continued their conversation for 10-15 seconds before addressing me. Amenities-wise, the pastry and drink options were solid in quantity and varied. The bagels were largely hidden from public view. Store signage looked good from what could be made out in the lighting. I declined a plastic bag and packed my purchases in my backpack away from the register. The previously disinterested staff watched me intently until I left the store. While I wouldn't necessarily recommend the experience, the intrigue was refreshing. 3.25

Bagel: Large bagel size, not cut all the way through. The overall profile typifies the 'average' bagel experience you'll find at most delis and unexceptional bagel stores. Standard toppings, both sides (kudos for that) at moderate density. A generic softness with the soggy, salty sheen of bagel brine. Limited crystal presence. Not stale but no sense of freshness and a little grainy. What brings the bagel up to store-bought average (versus the 2.5 supermarket bagel) is that salty flavoring painted onto the exterior. 3

Cream Cheese: Served deli case cool. Good amount but messy application. A little too dairy forward in taste, lacking a whipped freshness. On the plus side, the spread possesses a good scallion amount and strong texture presence. 3.25

Bagel Cafe

Baychester, Bronx

Bagel Cafe

Total Score

Ranks & Awards

3.17 / 5
#10 in Bronx #174 in NYC

Store: A long, deep store with strangely dim yellow lighting as you progress to the back. The effect is an aura of suspicion, like a thieves guild for bagels. Despite being the only customer in the store and having time to prepare for my approach, they continued their conversation for 10-15 seconds before addressing me. Amenities-wise, the pastry and drink options were solid in quantity and varied. The bagels were largely hidden from public view. Store signage looked good from what could be made out in the lighting. I declined a plastic bag and packed my purchases in my backpack away from the register. The previously disinterested staff watched me intently until I left the store. While I wouldn't necessarily recommend the experience, the intrigue was refreshing. 3.25

Bagel: Large bagel size, not cut all the way through. The overall profile typifies the 'average' bagel experience you'll find at most delis and unexceptional bagel stores. Standard toppings, both sides (kudos for that) at moderate density. A generic softness with the soggy, salty sheen of bagel brine. Limited crystal presence. Not stale but no sense of freshness and a little grainy. What brings the bagel up to store-bought average (versus the 2.5 supermarket bagel) is that salty flavoring painted onto the exterior. 3

Cream Cheese: Served deli case cool. Good amount but messy application. A little too dairy forward in taste, lacking a whipped freshness. On the plus side, the spread possesses a good scallion amount and strong texture presence. 3.25

Bagel Size and Texture

CracklyChewySmallX-Large

Seed and Salt Density

High Salt RatioLow Salt RatioTopping LightTopping Dense

Spread Ripeness and Texture

Fine ScallionCoarse ScallionDairy LatentDairy Forward

Store Style and Services

Variety of ServicesFocused ServicesClassicContemporary