Bagels & Co. - Upper West Side

Upper West Side, Manhattan

Bagels & Co. - Upper West Side

Total Score

Ranks & Awards

4.00 / 5
#25 in Manhattan #63 in NYC

Store: A nice, homey vibe. Stained glass lamp shades hang over the deli casing, forming a pleasant division between staff and customer. Good signage as well. Positioning itself as a one stop kosher shop with a pizza oven component. Moderate drink selection, good spread offerings, attractive pastry options. Fast, friendly staff. 4

Bagel: Large bagel. Moderate topping density on both sides, good salt ratio that plays decently into the flavor profile. In terms of freshness, past peak but not old. A very tough chew; my jaw hurt a bit after eating. As it was still reasonably fresh this is not so much a complaint as an observation. No crackle to the shell, just grip it and rip it. The handling of the toppings are where this bagel gets most of its kudos. 3.75

Cream Cheese: Served neutral temperature. Fresh, with a fluidity that verges on yogurt. No sense of undue dairy influence. Big, meaty scallion chunks. Plays well with the natural topping strengths of the bagel pairing. A very interesting spread. 4.25

Bagels & Co. - Upper West Side

Upper West Side, Manhattan

Bagels & Co. - Upper West Side

Total Score

Ranks & Awards

4.00 / 5
#25 in Manhattan #63 in NYC

Store: A nice, homey vibe. Stained glass lamp shades hang over the deli casing, forming a pleasant division between staff and customer. Good signage as well. Positioning itself as a one stop kosher shop with a pizza oven component. Moderate drink selection, good spread offerings, attractive pastry options. Fast, friendly staff. 4

Bagel: Large bagel. Moderate topping density on both sides, good salt ratio that plays decently into the flavor profile. In terms of freshness, past peak but not old. A very tough chew; my jaw hurt a bit after eating. As it was still reasonably fresh this is not so much a complaint as an observation. No crackle to the shell, just grip it and rip it. The handling of the toppings are where this bagel gets most of its kudos. 3.75

Cream Cheese: Served neutral temperature. Fresh, with a fluidity that verges on yogurt. No sense of undue dairy influence. Big, meaty scallion chunks. Plays well with the natural topping strengths of the bagel pairing. A very interesting spread. 4.25

Bagel Size and Texture

CracklyChewySmallX-Large

Seed and Salt Density

High Salt RatioLow Salt RatioTopping LightTopping Dense

Spread Ripeness and Texture

Fine ScallionCoarse ScallionDairy LatentDairy Forward

Store Style and Services

Variety of ServicesFocused ServicesClassicContemporary