Bagels On the Square

West Village, Manhattan

Bagels On the Square
View On OpenSea

Total Score

Ranks & Awards

2.83 / 5
#50 in Manhattan #189 in NYC

Store: Feels more like a chain sandwich shop interior. Slight bagel aroma in the store. Small drink selection, moderate cream cheese spread, lox on display. Bagels arranged with the care of a DVD collection - too much handling and not enough product turnover. Staff was fast in production but the check out was a little confused. 3

Bagel: Toppings on one side, some salt. Large bagel. Extra chewy but not crispy outer top shell, exceptionally soft bottom half. In the way, almost like a pie crust that gives at about the same pressure as a pop tart - minus the sweetness and the crumbling. Very strange bagel. 3

Cream Cheese: On the cooler side, non-descript in both manners good and bad. Scallion does nothing to modify the experience. 2.5

Bagels On the Square

West Village, Manhattan

Bagels On the Square

Total Score

Ranks & Awards

2.83 / 5
#50 in Manhattan #189 in NYC

Store: Feels more like a chain sandwich shop interior. Slight bagel aroma in the store. Small drink selection, moderate cream cheese spread, lox on display. Bagels arranged with the care of a DVD collection - too much handling and not enough product turnover. Staff was fast in production but the check out was a little confused. 3

Bagel: Toppings on one side, some salt. Large bagel. Extra chewy but not crispy outer top shell, exceptionally soft bottom half. In the way, almost like a pie crust that gives at about the same pressure as a pop tart - minus the sweetness and the crumbling. Very strange bagel. 3

Cream Cheese: On the cooler side, non-descript in both manners good and bad. Scallion does nothing to modify the experience. 2.5

Bagel Size and Texture

CracklyChewySmallX-Large

Seed and Salt Density

High Salt RatioLow Salt RatioTopping LightTopping Dense

Spread Ripeness and Texture

Fine ScallionCoarse ScallionDairy LatentDairy Forward

Store Style and Services

Variety of ServicesFocused ServicesClassicContemporary