Store: Spacious bagel-shoppe/deli with a highly produced deli case display. A wide variety of cream cheeses, each with its own decorative flourish. Lots of baked good options, bagels well-displayed and properly hampered. Quick, efficient bagel staff, wide drink selection. All that said, missing some of the je ne sais quoi of a true bagel store experience. 4

Bagel: Large bagel, though more modest by Staten Island standards. Sesame dominant topping blend, followed by garlic and poppy. Topping on one side. Salt not visible or noted on the shell. A soft, chewy bagel, not unpleasant but low character. The sesame-forward nature was the most enjoyable part, which could be unique to me eating the same type of bagel three times a week. 3.75

Cream Cheese: Good application amount. Served cold, a little clumped and flavor muted as a consequence. Freshness apparent. 3.75