Bagelsmith - Bedford Ave

Williamsburg, Brooklyn

Bagelsmith - Bedford Ave
View On OpenSea

Total Score

Ranks & Awards

4.17 / 5
#9 in Brooklyn #35 in NYC

Store: A fairly small, rectangular space with an "order here, pay there" ticket system. Contemporary atmosphere but not trying for any particular finish. Moderate drink selection, solid signage, mostly wrapped plastic pastry selection. Fast, professional, friendly staff. 4

Bagel: A medium-large bagel. Tall profile with an indent for a hole. Served fresh - very fresh for the time of day - but not hot. Indicative of good store turnover. One-sided standard toppings, fairly light, skewing onion/garlic dominant. Low salt ratio but not missed. Light fissures on bite. 4.25

Cream Cheese: Served at neutral temperature. A delectably fresh whip, dairy latent, with no hints of overcheese. Good application amount and even coverage across the bagel. Scallions are a strong chop size, further infusing freshness. A slightly lower ratio means less texture play, however. A solid bagel store spread. 4.25

Bagelsmith - Bedford Ave

Williamsburg, Brooklyn

Bagelsmith - Bedford Ave

Total Score

Ranks & Awards

4.17 / 5
#9 in Brooklyn #35 in NYC

Store: A fairly small, rectangular space with an "order here, pay there" ticket system. Contemporary atmosphere but not trying for any particular finish. Moderate drink selection, solid signage, mostly wrapped plastic pastry selection. Fast, professional, friendly staff. 4

Bagel: A medium-large bagel. Tall profile with an indent for a hole. Served fresh - very fresh for the time of day - but not hot. Indicative of good store turnover. One-sided standard toppings, fairly light, skewing onion/garlic dominant. Low salt ratio but not missed. Light fissures on bite. 4.25

Cream Cheese: Served at neutral temperature. A delectably fresh whip, dairy latent, with no hints of overcheese. Good application amount and even coverage across the bagel. Scallions are a strong chop size, further infusing freshness. A slightly lower ratio means less texture play, however. A solid bagel store spread. 4.25

Bagel Size and Texture

CracklyChewySmallX-Large

Seed and Salt Density

High Salt RatioLow Salt RatioTopping LightTopping Dense

Spread Ripeness and Texture

Fine ScallionCoarse ScallionDairy LatentDairy Forward

Store Style and Services

Variety of ServicesFocused ServicesClassicContemporary