Bunch-O-Bagels

Crown Heights, Brooklyn

Bunch-O-Bagels
View On OpenSea

Total Score

Ranks & Awards

2.50 / 5
#66 in Brooklyn #197 in NYC

Store: Unusual set-up: a large, boxy area at the entrance for tables (currently void from COVID), then a small set of stairs up to the ordering area. Ordering area uncomfortably small even for 4-5 people and going downstairs removes you from eyeline. No spreads visible, bare pastry section, low drink selection. Seemingly unhappy, definitely uninterested staff moving very slow for the volume of orders. The facilities did appear to be clean. 2.25

Bagel: Medium-sized bagel. Standard toppings. No salt, but well-applied on both sides. Soft, but no particular sensation of freshness. Perhaps too doughy. 3

Cream Cheese: Served around room temperature, good quantity. Completely unique texture - grainy and closer to white fish salad. Specs of green were the only indication it was scallion-based. The texture combined with the inherent nature of cream cheese being a dairy product was off-putting. Dips below the Philadelphia threshold less because of taste, but more because it feels like this place should know better. 2.25

Bunch-O-Bagels

Crown Heights, Brooklyn

Bunch-O-Bagels

Total Score

Ranks & Awards

2.50 / 5
#66 in Brooklyn #197 in NYC

Store: Unusual set-up: a large, boxy area at the entrance for tables (currently void from COVID), then a small set of stairs up to the ordering area. Ordering area uncomfortably small even for 4-5 people and going downstairs removes you from eyeline. No spreads visible, bare pastry section, low drink selection. Seemingly unhappy, definitely uninterested staff moving very slow for the volume of orders. The facilities did appear to be clean. 2.25

Bagel: Medium-sized bagel. Standard toppings. No salt, but well-applied on both sides. Soft, but no particular sensation of freshness. Perhaps too doughy. 3

Cream Cheese: Served around room temperature, good quantity. Completely unique texture - grainy and closer to white fish salad. Specs of green were the only indication it was scallion-based. The texture combined with the inherent nature of cream cheese being a dairy product was off-putting. Dips below the Philadelphia threshold less because of taste, but more because it feels like this place should know better. 2.25

Bagel Size and Texture

CracklyChewySmallX-Large

Seed and Salt Density

High Salt RatioLow Salt RatioTopping LightTopping Dense

Spread Ripeness and Texture

Fine ScallionCoarse ScallionDairy LatentDairy Forward

Store Style and Services

Variety of ServicesFocused ServicesClassicContemporary