Manor Superette and Bagels

Manor Heights, Staten Island

Manor Superette and Bagels

Total Score

Ranks & Awards

2.75 / 5
#18 in Staten Island #191 in NYC

Store: As the 'Superette' name may suggest, about the size and level of items as a stocked 7-11. Set up with bagel hoppers and cold display, novelty bagels and gf options. Order was handled fast. Despite the decals of playful bagels in the outside, not a place that captures the imagination for eating. 3

Bagel: Large bagel. About 80% of the topping was garlic, with some poppy and sesame lightly on one quarter. Salt not visually apparent but apparent on the bagel shell. If 2.5 is the water mark for a grocery store bagel, this rises just above. Would be more successful as a strictly garlic bagel. 2.75

Cream Cheese: Thinly applied but not good enough to desire more. The tang it provides is too close to - though does not achieve - undesirable. Scallion a non-factor. 2.5

Manor Superette and Bagels

Manor Heights, Staten Island

Manor Superette and Bagels

Total Score

Ranks & Awards

2.75 / 5
#18 in Staten Island #191 in NYC

Store: As the 'Superette' name may suggest, about the size and level of items as a stocked 7-11. Set up with bagel hoppers and cold display, novelty bagels and gf options. Order was handled fast. Despite the decals of playful bagels in the outside, not a place that captures the imagination for eating. 3

Bagel: Large bagel. About 80% of the topping was garlic, with some poppy and sesame lightly on one quarter. Salt not visually apparent but apparent on the bagel shell. If 2.5 is the water mark for a grocery store bagel, this rises just above. Would be more successful as a strictly garlic bagel. 2.75

Cream Cheese: Thinly applied but not good enough to desire more. The tang it provides is too close to - though does not achieve - undesirable. Scallion a non-factor. 2.5

Bagel Size and Texture

CracklyChewySmallX-Large

Seed and Salt Density

High Salt RatioLow Salt RatioTopping LightTopping Dense

Spread Ripeness and Texture

Fine ScallionCoarse ScallionDairy LatentDairy Forward

Store Style and Services

Variety of ServicesFocused ServicesClassicContemporary