Nagle’s Bagels

Bed-Stuy, Brooklyn

Nagle’s Bagels

Total Score

Ranks & Awards

3.67 / 5
#41 in Brooklyn #121 in NYC

Store: A small space, contemporary vibe, with stoop stairs for an entryway. Signage speaks to the artisanal style of bagel development. The means of production aren't immediately visible, though there is a back room of some kind. Very limited drink selection, friendly staff. Well intentioned and well executed. 4

Bagel: A large bagel with lovely, whorling terrain. Two-sided toppings at moderate to high density, standard everything topping. Several salt crystals but not much taste presence. A doughy chew with slight fissures on bite, chewier on the edges. The lack of salt representation ultimately hurts the experience some. 3.5

Cream Cheese: Served room temperature. Messy application, with cream cheese on shell and some other substance - possibly red pepper paste - left on the prep knife in haste. Scallion is visible but not much texture. Neutral dairy profile. Good amount applied. 3.5

Nagle’s Bagels

Bed-Stuy, Brooklyn

Nagle’s Bagels

Total Score

Ranks & Awards

3.67 / 5
#41 in Brooklyn #121 in NYC

Store: A small space, contemporary vibe, with stoop stairs for an entryway. Signage speaks to the artisanal style of bagel development. The means of production aren't immediately visible, though there is a back room of some kind. Very limited drink selection, friendly staff. Well intentioned and well executed. 4

Bagel: A large bagel with lovely, whorling terrain. Two-sided toppings at moderate to high density, standard everything topping. Several salt crystals but not much taste presence. A doughy chew with slight fissures on bite, chewier on the edges. The lack of salt representation ultimately hurts the experience some. 3.5

Cream Cheese: Served room temperature. Messy application, with cream cheese on shell and some other substance - possibly red pepper paste - left on the prep knife in haste. Scallion is visible but not much texture. Neutral dairy profile. Good amount applied. 3.5

Bagel Size and Texture

CracklyChewySmallX-Large

Seed and Salt Density

High Salt RatioLow Salt RatioTopping LightTopping Dense

Spread Ripeness and Texture

Fine ScallionCoarse ScallionDairy LatentDairy Forward

Store Style and Services

Variety of ServicesFocused ServicesClassicContemporary