NY Jumbo Bagels
Sutton Place, Manhattan
Total Score
Ranks & Awards
Store: From the outside in, a powerfully nonchalant orange motif permeates the store. Orange signage, orange awning, fake orange foliage in the deli case. Very lived-in atmosphere with professional, bagel store staffing. Belly lox on display, salad bar and other deli amenities. Moderate to large drink selection. Demerits for the pastry selection. A great local spot. 4
Bagel: Large bagel, not hot but very fresh. Standard toppings on both sides, light and uneven on bottom. Salt present at a good ratio. Bagel not cut through all the way. Wonderfully browned shell, toasty crackle at the edge bites. A slightly tough chew in a good way. This is a good bagel. 4.25
Cream Cheese: Served deli case cold. Excellent quantity, even though slightly messy application. Very fresh, all elements working in harmony so as no one component stands out. 4.25