Oakwood Bagels

Oakwood Heights, Staten Island

Oakwood Bagels
View On OpenSea

Total Score

Ranks & Awards

2.67 / 5
#19 in Staten Island #193 in NYC

Store: Despite the name, the store is essentially a deli with bagel options. As such, a large drink selection and variety of services offered but not truly bagel-focused. A cooking competition rerun plays on Food Network over the flat screen. The staff doesn't seem interested on being there. On the plus side, their rainbow bagel takes a very exotic, pink-hued approach. 3

Bagel: A chewy bagel on the small side of the spectrum. It's too early in the day for a bagel to lack any freshness qualities, but here we are. Grainy, bland and without salt presence, it shares more trails with a roll than a bagel. One-sided toppings applied in a nicely irregular scatter pattern. But looks don't always translate to taste. 2.5

Cream Cheese: Scraped from a tupperware container in the deli case. Uneven application, decent amount. A very clotted texture, suffering from the dreaded sensation of overcheese. Scallions provide some texture but no taste considerations. 2.5

Oakwood Bagels

Oakwood Heights, Staten Island

Oakwood Bagels

Total Score

Ranks & Awards

2.67 / 5
#19 in Staten Island #193 in NYC

Store: Despite the name, the store is essentially a deli with bagel options. As such, a large drink selection and variety of services offered but not truly bagel-focused. A cooking competition rerun plays on Food Network over the flat screen. The staff doesn't seem interested on being there. On the plus side, their rainbow bagel takes a very exotic, pink-hued approach. 3

Bagel: A chewy bagel on the small side of the spectrum. It's too early in the day for a bagel to lack any freshness qualities, but here we are. Grainy, bland and without salt presence, it shares more trails with a roll than a bagel. One-sided toppings applied in a nicely irregular scatter pattern. But looks don't always translate to taste. 2.5

Cream Cheese: Scraped from a tupperware container in the deli case. Uneven application, decent amount. A very clotted texture, suffering from the dreaded sensation of overcheese. Scallions provide some texture but no taste considerations. 2.5

Bagel Size and Texture

CracklyChewySmallX-Large

Seed and Salt Density

High Salt RatioLow Salt RatioTopping LightTopping Dense

Spread Ripeness and Texture

Fine ScallionCoarse ScallionDairy LatentDairy Forward

Store Style and Services

Variety of ServicesFocused ServicesClassicContemporary